Last night, one of my worst nightmares came true: there was a mouse in the (garret) house.
Why it decided to come all the way up to my attic unit rather than stay in the lovely warm laundry room basement I do not know. Perhaps my landlord dragged it in yesterday when he raked a path of scattered leaves straight to the front door.
Hannah was napping in the garret living room, over by the window, on what has become her and her little brother Sam’s bunk bed. Sam was nowhere to be seen.
It was 9:15 p.m. and I was sitting in the living room, unable to find anything good on network television to help unwind my PTSD-ridden mind before bed. I decided to work on revising the chapter-by-chapter outline of Hannah Grace, the book, and had just begun to really focus when an odd crunching sound broke my concentration.
It was coming from the garret kitchenette. Because Hannah was asleep by the window, I thought it must be Sam. He tends to graze on Hannah’s kibble in between his kitten-formula meals. At four months old, Sam recently lost several baby teeth, and so I can distinguish between Hannah’s and Sam’s kibble-crunching sounds.
This crunching was different.
I left the living room for the kitchenette, where I saw Sam on the floor by the pantry, his head sticking deep into the bottom corner where I keep some old boxes. I thought perhaps he had found something to chew on; lately, he’s begun teething and, subsequently, he has become addicted to drooling on and hole-punching anything paper: a box of tissues, my bills, the Petco receipt for 54 cans of kitten food, and my students’ composition papers.
“Sam,” I insisted, thinking he was chewing on some packaging, “No.”
Sam retracted his head from the pantry, looked at me quizzically, then raced away. I went back to the living room, where I saw him become interested, momentarily, in a mouse toy on the floor, and then, uncharacteristically, he abandoned the living room quickly and quietly.
A few moments later, I heard the strange crunching again. Hannah remained asleep, unfazed. I left my chair and tiptoed towards the kitchenette.
There, I saw Sam sitting squarely in front of the refrigerator with a dead mouse at his feet, his adult incisors taking a bite out of its crunchy hind.
“Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh!” I sounded like an alarm. “Ohhhhhhhhhhhh!”
Sam stopped, mid-bite, and looked in my eyes as if waiting for my gratitude. He met my sense of horror with a sense of accomplishment, and licked his lips. Then he jumped over the mouse and left me to pick up the pieces.
Feeling as if I might vomit, I considered my options. Regular readers of this blog may recall my post this past August about the garret landlord (“Mr. Fix-It”) and will understand my decision not to ask him for any help. I decided to take mouse matters into my own hands.
I told myself I just had to get through it. Looking at its innocent ashen face, putty-like gray body and tail, I knew I couldn’t just throw it in the trash and it was too late to go outside to the dumpster, where there would surely be live mice, if not rats and criminals, lurking.
Scorning the garret and my landlord, I put on plastic gloves, took a grocery store bag from under the sink and wadded up a half a roll of paper towels to make a broom-like scooper, which I used to brush the mouse from the floor. I tied the handles of the bag, opened the garret door, and threw it. It tumbled, like a murder victim, down the stairs, landing at the back escape door of the two unfriendly men who share the unit below me.
As I imagined the mouse coming back alive, climbing the stairs and haunting me in the middle of the night, I inspected the pantry, in which I had found a quarter-sized hole last spring. At that time, Hannah had been sniffing quite heavily and insistently there. I had plugged it with steel wool and duct tape. When I examined my work last night, I found it secure. However, I saw that part of the floorboard had come away from the wall, leaving a nickel-sized gap where I imagined any mouse could enter. I spent the next hour scouring the garret, filling its voids.
I wondered if the mouse had been leftover from last spring. Had it been dead in the pantry for months? Was that why it “crunched” upon Sam’s contact, or was any mouse crunchy? Or, was this mouse a part of a family, whose goal it was to chase me out of my home? I had not seen any signs of chewing or mouse droppings and hoped, as my friend Steve assured me, it was just “a rogue mousie” or “a past tenant.”
I tried to wash my hands of it all, and returned to the living room, where I found Hannah and Sam sleeping as if nothing had happened at all. How could they be so calm and content?, I wondered. I worried momentarily that perhaps someone had put mouse killer in the house and the mouse ate it, and in turn Sam was about to die himself: “Oh hello, PTSD,” I thought, “I remember you….”
This morning, I tentatively approached the kitchenette, fearing a replay of last night’s sight, but, to my relief, there was nothing. This afternoon, I tiptoed to the basement, where the two washer-dryers are located, and stole three sheets of Bounce to try my college friend Kristin’s offered remedy: mice hate the smell of fabric softener sheets.
– TLS
I continue to enjoy your comments. Please share your thoughts below!






Hi Tracy: As you know I encountered a mouse massacre about a month ago. Tony killed 3 in 3 hours, and I could not sleep for days after. I finally gave in and had an exterminator come, (all he did was set some poison behind the stove). But what he did say was that since this is just before the onset of winter, mice are scrambling to find shelter and often losing their instincts in the process, showing behavior they often would not show and making mistakes. Those three little (now blind) mice probably lost their mom and were looking for food in places they would not normally go. I would think yours is a one time thing. If you do not want to set traps (which I did not), you can get these sonar or sonic like things you put in the outlet, and I think the mice do not like the sound of it.
hope all is well.
Kyna, thanks for your comment and for sharing your story about Tony. What a scene! As for the mice trying to find some shelter, I don’t see why they would want the garret as it’s freezing in here. Okay, that is an understatement, but it is chilly. But it is probably a little bit warmer than the unit below me, where the tenants are refusing to turn on their heat (which usually warms the garret without my having to turn my moisture-sucking electric radiator on). I don’t have the $$ for the sonar alternative (and I hear that can also aggravate some cats?) but bought a can of foam spray the professionals use to fill in the floor/wall gap (my aim was a tad… off… it was like aiming spray cheese through a straw!) and a box of Bounce. I certainly don’t intend to remain in the garret forever, so, other than the above, I think I’m just going to let Sam-kitten do his handiwork (if I can stand it).
Oh yes, the sound of the crunch. I know it well. Usually it would begin under my bed in the middle of the night. It seems amplified by an odd sort of stereo. “It must be the sound of the skull’s bones that are louder” my son announced when he was about seven. Well, at least it’s one less mouse to run around your house!
And yet again I must say that Sam is one handsome dude!
I have so many cats that there are toys all over the floor. One day I noticed a mouse toy that looked a little different, but I didn’t think much of it. I kept looking at it though because the tail was a little longer than usual toys… and most mouse toys don’t have 4 pink feet sticking up in the air… and OH NO! It’s a headless mouse. AAAAAHHHHHHHHH! I did the same thing you did. Used 1/2 a roll of paper towels to scoop it up and threw it over the balcony into the backyard. None of my cats seemed especially proud of themselves, so no one admitted to the deed, but at least it was dead and not alive.
It’s what cats do. Sounds like Sam’s good at it, which means you won’t ever have a little intruder ever again. Which is good–no little mice turds, no fleas and lice, no chewed on electrical wires.
I had a cat once who liked to… urm… crunch on the mice until there was only a head, spine, and tail left. Usually, this morbid little gift was left on the front porch for us to find on our way out the door to the school bus (our cats used to be indoor/outdoor cats). Another cat used to like to leave me presents–little mousie carcasses–under the covers. It was a little too God Father for my liking.
I have this theory that runs counter to the theory that cats who leave mice are leaving “presents” for their beloved humans. They aren’t presents… they’re REMINDERS. It as though our feline friends are saying, “Remember, human, I could kill you in your sleep.”
Mice sound crunchie in whatever state – fresh or old. And cats love to show them off, as if they have done something truly wonderful. My daughter has a cat who is 14, and in the last year or so, he has become an accomplished mouser. I regularly get lurid descriptions of his latest massacre – the last one was 3 baby mice. And she lives on the third floor of her building! The exterminator came yesterday, so Tony’s mouse-hunting days have been cut short. I must admit a certain admiration and respect for his late-blooming career as a mouser.
Deirdre, I appreciate your comment. I’m still completely wigged out by the mouse incident and would not wish upon anyone what your daughter has endured. I don’t quite get why mice would prefer a unit so high up, unless a garret is really a mouse’s penthouse.
I still think having the cats take care of the mice is better than the mice running wild….still, I didn’t “man up” enough to deal with the mice our cats got until Andrew sprained his ankle this summer and I had to deal with the two that Stokely and Rosie got while he was seriously laid up. I’m just thankful the Bounce seems to be working!
Thanks, Kristin, for relating your story. I just have to ask, how often should the Bounce be replaced to remain effective?